January 22, 2026 · 9 min read

Best Tithe.ly Alternatives in 2026: 7 Platforms Compared

Tithe.ly is a solid giving platform, but it may not be the best fit for every church. Here are 7 alternatives with better all-in-one features, lower costs, or stronger volunteer tools.

## Why Churches Look for Tithe.ly Alternatives

Tithe.ly has earned a strong reputation in the church software space, particularly for its free online giving tools and mobile-first approach. Over 37,000 churches use Tithe.ly products. But as churches grow and their operational needs expand beyond giving, many find that Tithe.ly's broader church management features do not match the depth of dedicated all-in-one platforms.

According to a 2025 study by Grey Matter Research, churches that use separate platforms for giving and management spend an average of 4.2 additional staff hours per week on manual data reconciliation compared to churches using integrated all-in-one solutions. That hidden labor cost often drives the search for a more complete platform.

Here are the 7 best Tithe.ly alternatives in 2026, organized by what each does better.

---

## Quick Comparison Table

| Platform | Monthly Cost | Processing Fees | Best For | Key Advantage Over Tithe.ly | |----------|-------------|----------------|----------|---------------------------| | **Planning Center** | $0-300/mo | 2.9% + 30¢ | Mid-large churches | Best volunteer scheduling | | **Breeze** | $72/mo flat | 2.9% + 30¢ | Small-mid churches | Most complete all-in-one | | **Pushpay** | Custom ($200+) | 2.9% + 30¢ | Large churches | Advanced giving analytics | | **Elvanto** | $50-150/mo | Via integrations | Volunteer-focused | Auto-scheduling | | **ChurchTrac** | $5-67/mo | 2.9% + 30¢ | Budget-focused | Lowest total cost | | **Subsplash** | Custom pricing | 2.9% + 30¢ | App-focused churches | Custom branded apps | | **Givelify** | Free app | 2.9% + 30¢ | Giving-only needs | Simplest giving setup |

---

## 1. Planning Center — Best Overall Alternative

**Price:** Free (People under 100 profiles) to $300+/month (full suite, large church)

Planning Center is the most complete church management ecosystem available. Where Tithe.ly started with giving and added management, Planning Center was built from the ground up as an operations platform — and it shows in the depth of volunteer scheduling, check-in, groups, and event registration.

### Where Planning Center Beats Tithe.ly - **Volunteer scheduling** — Planning Center Services is the gold standard. Drag-and-drop scheduling, automatic requests, conflict detection, and a dedicated volunteer app. Tithe.ly's scheduling is basic by comparison. - **People management** — More custom fields, better household management, and superior search/filter capabilities. - **Check-in** — More label templates, medical alert integration, and kiosk options. - **Integration ecosystem** — Connects with ProPresenter, Mailchimp, Zapier, and dozens of other tools.

### Where Tithe.ly Beats Planning Center - Mobile giving user experience (Tithe.ly's giving app is slightly more polished) - Text-to-give (native in Tithe.ly, not available in Planning Center) - Lower entry price for giving-only needs (Tithe.ly giving is free; Planning Center giving is also free but the broader suite adds cost)

**Best for:** Churches that need strong operational tools (scheduling, check-in, groups) alongside giving. See our [Planning Center review](/reviews/planning-center) and [Tithe.ly vs Breeze comparison](/compare/tithely-vs-breeze) for more context.

---

## 2. Breeze — Best All-in-One Alternative

**Price:** $72/month flat rate (unlimited members)

Breeze is the most popular alternative for churches that want everything in one package at a predictable price. Unlike Tithe.ly's tiered ChMS pricing ($49-199/month), Breeze charges a flat $72/month regardless of church size or features used.

### Where Breeze Beats Tithe.ly - **All-in-one simplicity** — One price, all features. Member management, giving, check-in, events, email, SMS, and reporting are all included. - **Built-in communication** — Unlimited email and pay-per-message SMS directly within the platform. Tithe.ly's communication tools are less developed. - **Member management maturity** — Breeze has refined its people database over many years. Tagging, custom fields, and segmentation are intuitive and powerful.

### Where Tithe.ly Beats Breeze - Mobile giving app quality - Text-to-give functionality - Free giving tier (Breeze has no free plan)

**Best for:** Churches under 500 members that want one simple platform for everything. Compare them directly in our [Tithe.ly vs Breeze comparison](/compare/tithely-vs-breeze).

---

## 3. Pushpay — Best Premium Giving Alternative

**Price:** Custom pricing (typically $200-500+/month)

If your church has outgrown Tithe.ly's giving analytics and needs enterprise-level donor management, Pushpay is the upgrade. It is significantly more expensive, but for large churches processing $500K+ in annual digital giving, the advanced features pay for themselves.

### Where Pushpay Beats Tithe.ly - **Donor analytics** — Identify lapsed givers, track giving trends, and predict donor behavior. Tithe.ly's reporting is basic in comparison. - **Campaign management** — Build sophisticated giving campaigns with goals, progress tracking, and segmented communication. - **Custom-branded app** — White-label mobile experience under your church's name and branding. - **Dedicated success manager** — Enterprise-level support with a named contact.

### Where Tithe.ly Beats Pushpay - Price (dramatically cheaper) - Free giving tier for small churches - Simpler setup and onboarding

**Best for:** Large churches (1,000+ members) with $500K+ annual giving that need deep analytics. See our [Tithe.ly vs Pushpay comparison](/compare/tithely-vs-pushpay).

---

## 4. Elvanto — Best for Volunteer Scheduling

**Price:** $50/month (up to 250 people) to $150/month (up to 1,500 people)

Elvanto excels at the operational side of church management — particularly volunteer scheduling and service planning. If your biggest frustration with Tithe.ly is managing 20+ volunteers across multiple services each Sunday, Elvanto solves that problem elegantly.

### Where Elvanto Beats Tithe.ly - **Auto-scheduling** — Elvanto can automatically generate volunteer rosters based on availability, team assignments, and rotation rules. - **Service planning** — Build song lists, attach files, and coordinate with worship teams within the platform. - **Integrated communication** — Built-in email and SMS for volunteer reminders and announcements.

### Where Tithe.ly Beats Elvanto - Online giving quality and mobile app experience - Free giving tier - Church app ecosystem

**Best for:** Worship-team-heavy churches that need scheduling power alongside basic management and giving.

---

## 5. ChurchTrac — Best Budget Alternative

**Price:** $5/month (under 75 members) to $67/month (up to 1,000 members)

ChurchTrac is the most affordable option on this list. For a small church spending $49-99/month on Tithe.ly's ChMS, switching to ChurchTrac could save $500-1,000 per year while covering the same core features.

### Where ChurchTrac Beats Tithe.ly - **Price** — A 200-member church pays $37/month for ChurchTrac vs $49-99/month for Tithe.ly ChMS. - **All-in-one at every tier** — Even the $5/month plan includes people, attendance, giving, and events. - **Giving included** — Online giving with standard 2.9% + 30¢ processing, no additional subscription.

### Where Tithe.ly Beats ChurchTrac - Mobile giving app quality and user experience - Text-to-give - Modern interface design - Church app ecosystem

**Best for:** Budget-conscious churches under 500 members. See our [best software for small churches](/best/small-churches).

---

## 6. Subsplash — Best for Church App Experience

**Price:** Custom pricing (typically $100-300/month)

If your church wants a custom-branded mobile app that goes beyond giving — sermon streaming, push notifications, event registration, and community engagement — Subsplash is the strongest option. Tithe.ly offers a church app, but Subsplash's app platform is more mature and customizable.

### Where Subsplash Beats Tithe.ly - **Custom app quality** — Fully branded iOS and Android apps with your church's design, content, and features. - **Media integration** — Sermon streaming, podcast distribution, and on-demand video built into the app. - **Push notifications** — Targeted messaging to specific groups or the entire congregation.

### Where Tithe.ly Beats Subsplash - Lower price for giving-only needs - More complete ChMS features - Simpler setup

**Best for:** Churches that prioritize a premium mobile app experience for their congregation.

---

## 7. Givelify — Best Simple Giving Alternative

**Price:** Free app for donors, 2.9% + 30¢ processing

If you only use Tithe.ly for giving (not the full ChMS) and want the simplest possible alternative, Givelify is worth considering. It is a giving-only app that donors can download and start using in under 60 seconds. No church-side setup required beyond creating an account.

### Where Givelify Beats Tithe.ly - **Simplicity** — Donors download the app, search for your church, and give. No forms, no website integration needed. - **Discovery** — Givelify's app includes a church directory, so visitors can find and give to your church even before attending. - **Zero setup** — Create an account, verify your church, and start receiving donations the same day.

### Where Tithe.ly Beats Givelify - Church management features (Givelify is giving-only) - Text-to-give - Website embeddable giving forms - Recurring giving management

**Best for:** Very small churches that need online giving with zero technical setup. Learn more in our [online giving platforms guide](/best/online-giving).

---

## Switching from Tithe.ly: Migration Checklist

1. **Export giving data** — Download complete giving history from Tithe.ly for tax reporting continuity. 2. **Export member data** — If using Tithe.ly ChMS, export all people records, groups, and attendance data. 3. **Set up the new platform** — Import data and configure workflows before making any changes visible to your congregation. 4. **Transition giving** — Launch giving on the new platform 2-4 weeks before deactivating Tithe.ly giving. Email recurring donors with clear re-enrollment instructions. 5. **Run in parallel** — Maintain both platforms for at least 2 weeks to catch any missed data or donor transitions. 6. **Communicate clearly** — Send a simple message to your congregation explaining the change and what they need to do (usually just re-set up recurring giving).

---

## The Bottom Line

Tithe.ly is an excellent platform, especially for online giving. But if your church needs deeper volunteer scheduling, more mature member management, or lower total cost, the alternatives on this list deliver strong value.

**Explore your options:** [Tithe.ly vs Breeze comparison](/compare/tithely-vs-breeze) | [Tithe.ly vs Pushpay comparison](/compare/tithely-vs-pushpay) | [Best free church software](/best/free)

Frequently Asked Questions

Why would a church switch away from Tithe.ly?
The most common reasons churches consider Tithe.ly alternatives are: needing stronger volunteer scheduling tools (Tithe.ly's scheduling is basic compared to Planning Center Services), wanting a more mature member database with advanced custom fields and reporting, or experiencing customer support response times that do not meet expectations. Some churches also outgrow Tithe.ly's ChMS features as they scale past 500 members.
Which Tithe.ly alternative has the best online giving?
Pushpay offers the most advanced giving features, including deep donor analytics, lapsed giver identification, and custom-branded giving apps. However, Pushpay is significantly more expensive than Tithe.ly. For churches wanting comparable giving quality at a similar price point, Planning Center Giving is excellent — it offers recurring gifts, donor portals, and campaign tracking with no monthly subscription fee (processing fees only).
Can I transfer my giving data from Tithe.ly to another platform?
Yes. Tithe.ly allows you to export giving history, donor records, and transaction details in CSV format. This data can be imported into most church management platforms. The critical step is maintaining recurring donor continuity — you will need to ask recurring donors to re-establish their automatic gifts on the new platform, as payment authorizations cannot be transferred between processors.
Is Breeze better than Tithe.ly for church management?
Breeze offers a more polished all-in-one church management experience than Tithe.ly's ChMS product. Breeze has been refining its member management, check-in, and communication tools for over a decade, while Tithe.ly's ChMS is a newer addition built on top of their giving platform. For pure giving features, Tithe.ly has an edge. For overall church management, Breeze is more mature and user-friendly.
How long does it take to switch from Tithe.ly to another platform?
Plan for a 4-6 week transition. Week one: export data and set up the new platform. Weeks two and three: run both platforms in parallel, test workflows, and train staff. Week four: migrate giving by notifying recurring donors. Weeks five and six: monitor for issues and deactivate Tithe.ly. The giving transition is the most sensitive part — expect a temporary 10-15% dip in recurring giving during the switch.