Best Tithely Alternatives for Churches in 2026
Tithely has become a popular all-in-one church platform, but it is not the perfect fit for every congregation. Whether you need deeper church management, better worship planning, or a different approach to giving, these five alternatives are worth considering.
Why People Switch from Tithely
- 1Worship planning and service scheduling tools are limited — churches with complex production needs often outgrow what Tithely offers.
- 2The ChMS features, while improving, still lack the depth of dedicated church management platforms for larger congregations.
- 3Reporting and analytics can feel basic when you need detailed financial breakdowns, custom dashboards, or multi-campus views.
- 4Some churches experience slower customer support response times during peak seasons like year-end giving campaigns.
- 5The all-in-one bundled approach means you pay for features you may not use if you only need giving or only need a ChMS.
Top 5 Tithely Alternatives
#1
Planning Center
Modular church management platform
4.6
Price: Free – $399/mo (per module)
Key differentiator: Industry-leading modular architecture lets churches pick and pay for only the tools they need — from people management to worship services to check-ins.
Pros
- Best-in-class worship planning with Planning Center Services
- Modular pricing means you only pay for what you use
- Excellent check-in system trusted by thousands of churches
- Deep volunteer scheduling with automated reminders
- Large ecosystem with extensive third-party integrations
Cons
- Costs add up when you subscribe to multiple modules
- Online giving tools are less feature-rich than Tithely
- No built-in website builder or custom church app
- Can feel complex for small churches that want simplicity
#2
Breeze ChMS
Simple, affordable church management
4.8
Price: $72 – $495/mo
Key differentiator: The easiest ChMS on the market — churches get set up in minutes with an intuitive interface that even the least tech-savvy volunteers can master.
Pros
- Incredibly simple setup and daily use
- Flat-rate pricing with unlimited users and contacts
- Excellent people management and follow-up tools
- Built-in giving with easy donor management
- Top-rated customer support with fast response times
Cons
- No worship planning or service scheduling features
- Giving transaction fees are higher than Tithely
- Limited customization for complex church workflows
- No custom church mobile app for members
#3
Pushpay
Mobile-first giving platform
4.4
Price: Custom pricing (typically $199+/mo)
Key differentiator: Highest mobile giving adoption rates in the church space, with a frictionless donation experience that consistently increases digital giving by 60% or more.
Pros
- Unmatched mobile giving experience and adoption rates
- Branded app with deep giving integration
- Advanced donor analytics and engagement insights
- Strong recurring giving tools that reduce donor churn
- Enterprise-grade reliability for large churches
Cons
- Significantly more expensive than Tithely
- Requires separate platform for full church management
- Multi-year contracts limit flexibility
- Not cost-effective for churches under 300 members
#4
Church Community Builder
Enterprise-grade church management system
4.2
Price: Custom pricing (typically $250+/mo)
Key differentiator: Purpose-built assimilation pathways and process queues help large churches systematically move people from first-time visitors to fully engaged members.
Pros
- Deep group management with leader-specific dashboards
- Process queues for tracking assimilation and follow-ups
- Comprehensive reporting for data-driven ministry decisions
- Background check integration for volunteer screening
- Native integration with Pushpay for giving
Cons
- User interface feels dated compared to modern platforms
- Complex setup requires dedicated training sessions
- No transparent public pricing — requires sales call
- Overly complex for churches under 500 members
#5
Subsplash
Church app and engagement platform
4.5
Price: $149 – $499/mo
Key differentiator: The most polished custom church mobile app on the market, combining media streaming, giving, and engagement into one beautifully branded experience.
Pros
- Industry-leading custom church mobile app design
- Integrated giving with competitive processing rates
- Sermon streaming, podcasting, and media hosting built in
- Push notifications for direct congregation engagement
- Professional, modern experience that impresses visitors
Cons
- Church management features are less mature than Tithely
- Higher entry price than Tithely's free tier
- App design changes require Subsplash team involvement
- Reporting capabilities are still developing
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Planning Center | Breeze | Pushpay | CCB | Subsplash |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Online Giving | |||||
| Church Mobile App | |||||
| People Management | |||||
| Worship Planning | |||||
| Group Management | |||||
| Volunteer Scheduling | |||||
| Free Tier Available | |||||
| Starting Price | Free | $72/mo | $199+/mo | $250+/mo | $149/mo |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I migrate my data from Tithely to another platform?▼
Yes, Tithely allows you to export your people, giving, and group data as CSV files. Most alternatives like Breeze, Planning Center, and CCB offer CSV import tools or migration assistance. Budget 1–2 weeks for a complete migration, including verifying donor records and giving history.
Which Tithely alternative has the best online giving?▼
Pushpay leads in mobile giving adoption and donor engagement, but at a significantly higher price. For churches that want strong giving at a lower cost, Breeze and Subsplash both offer solid online giving with competitive transaction fees. Planning Center Giving is also a reliable option.
What is the best Tithely alternative for small churches?▼
Breeze ChMS is the best Tithely alternative for small churches. Its flat-rate pricing, instant setup, and volunteer-friendly interface make it ideal for congregations under 200 members. Planning Center's free tier is also worth considering if you only need basic people management.
Does any Tithely alternative offer a free plan?▼
Planning Center offers free tiers for several of its modules, including People (up to a limited number of records) and other tools. However, no alternative matches Tithely's free ChMS and giving combination. If cost is your primary concern, Planning Center's free People module plus a separate free giving tool is the closest equivalent.
Is Tithely still a good choice in 2026?▼
Tithely remains one of the best value propositions in church software, especially for small to mid-size churches that want giving, a ChMS, a website, and a mobile app in one platform. However, if you need advanced worship planning, enterprise-level reporting, or the highest mobile giving adoption rates, the alternatives above may serve you better.